The Rise of AI Search: How It Impacts Brands, Traffic, and Trust

Explore how AI search is reshaping trust, traffic, and branding, and what your business needs to do to stay ahead.

Butter Team

May 30, 2025

The shift from search engines to AI tools like ChatGPT represents more than just a change in how we look up information — it’s a transformation in how users engage with brands.


From Search to Answer

AI tools don’t send users to websites. They provide direct answers — curated, summarized, and cited (sometimes). That means fewer opportunities for organic clicks, but higher trust for brands that do get mentioned.


Why Trust Matters

Being included in an AI-generated answer lends authority. Users assume the AI has chosen credible, relevant sources. If your brand is mentioned, it instantly benefits from that perceived trust.


Traffic is Changing

AI search is reducing reliance on traditional search traffic. That means:

  • Less emphasis on organic click-through rates
  • More value in brand awareness and entity optimization
  • A growing need to measure visibility beyond Google Analytics


What This Means for Brands

You can’t afford to ignore AI-driven discovery. Brands that get cited in AI tools gain an edge — they’re seen as credible, established, and trustworthy. Those that don’t? They’re invisible in the tools consumers now rely on for answers.


How to Get Ahead

  • Publish valuable, verifiable content in places AI crawls
  • Ensure your brand identity is consistent and structured
  • Monitor how AI tools respond to prompts in your niche
  • Treat AI SEO as a long-term visibility investment

Learn about our GEO approach

SERVICE BRIEF

Generative Engine Optimization from Butter

AI engines like ChatGPT are changing how people discover products and services. Instead of showing ten blue links like Google, they generate direct answers, pulling from trusted sources across the web. This guide breaks down how Butter’s GEO service helps your website become one of those trusted sources.

Join the growing number of websites partnering with Butter to manage their GEO and SEO

Show up in Google, ChatGPT, and AI search with Butter's GEO + SEO services. Starting at $159/month. No contract options. Cancel anytime.